Marc
45p53 comments posted · 2 followers · following 3
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - 2014 Supercoach & AFL ... · 0 replies · 0 points
Wombat and Jock, you're both right. I don't like to question those in the football community employed by clubs, but I cannot understand how some teams completely overlook genuine footy skills in favor of beep tests and such as you mentioned Jock. Matt Crouch has been compared to Matt Priddis, one of the most consistent midfielders in the game. I reckon if you got that sort of quality out of pick #23, you'd be laughing all the way to the bank.
Someone else also mentioned to me that the Crows may have lucked out somewhat this year due to several teams like GWS, Collingwood, Brisbans and St. Kilda having multiple selections in the top 25 which meant they may have gone for a needs based player with their 2nd or 3rd picks, rather than just taking the best guy on the board.
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Pick the order of this... · 0 replies · +1 points
If i'm Collingwood and he slides down to #10, i'd be on my knees thanking the football gods that I just scored a dead set gun midfielder.
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Pick the order of this... · 2 replies · +5 points
Nice list Jock, I tell you what, you'd be doing a couch jump if you guys draft James Aish. He will be a deadset gun, and make an excellent start to your rebuild project.
OK, here's how I see the top 10 going down.
Lock in the first two GWS as easy picks
Pick #1 - Tom Boyd
Pick #2 - Josh Kelly
St. Kilda Pick #3 - Jack Billings. I think they should take Aish or Scharenberg, who i'm bloody high as a hot air balloon for, but they'll still get a great player in Billings.
Western Bulldogs Pick #4 - James Aish. Ignore the stuff about him not being able to handle a tag. He's 18 years old, he'll learn to deal with pressure of AFL football. Add him to a midfield of Boyd, Griffen, Cooney and the young dogs Liberatore and Wallis and that's starting to shape up nicely.
Gold Coast Pick #5 - Everyone seems deadset on the Suns picking Kade Kolodjashnij, so who am I to argue?
Collingwood Pick #6 - Matt Scharenberg. Could be James Aish if he's not selected by the Bulldogs, but most likely Matt Scharenberg. He'll be a great pickup for them and will slot into the vacated Heath Shaw spot, without the temper tantrums. I'll hate Collingwood so much in this draft if they score Aish and Scharenberg though.
Brisbane Pick #7 - Marcus Bontempelli. Could be Cameron McCarthy as the Jonno Brown replacement if Bontempelli is picked before 7, but this looks like a good pick to me.
North Melbourne Pick #8 - Luke McDonald. F/S pick. Next.
Melbourne Pick #9 - Nathan Freeman. Agree with you on this pick, Jock. Melbourne recruited Bernie Vince from the Crows, who'll provide some help, but they'll still need some more bodies in the midfield.
Collingwood Pick #10 - Cameron McCarthy. I know the Pies recruited Jesse White to play alongside Cloke, but he's a bit of an also ran to me and will constantly tantalize the tastebuds with a good game every month, but provide duds the rest of the time. But this will at least allow McCarthy to spend the year in the VFL with White and Lynch ahead of him and be ready to take over the spot when he's good to go.
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Supercoach 2014 turnco... · 0 replies · +1 points
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Supercoach 2014 turnco... · 0 replies · +4 points
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Supercoach 2014 turnco... · 2 replies · +4 points
As for the byes, does anyone else like to use the "bring the game into disrepute for a week" (remember, there's no such thing as tanking) strategy? I've used this before as I found it less stressful to say for 1 week "OK, I've got 14-15 guys out this week, the rest of you blokes take it easy and we'll regroup for the next 2 bye rounds". That way i'll only have maybe 4-6 guys out for the next 2 bye rounds and not have to worry about wasting trades or being 1-2 guys short to field a full side.
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Supercoach 2014 turnco... · 0 replies · +2 points
I'll also still be keeping an eye on Sam Jacobs during the preseason. Still a good tap ruckman, so hopefully he can go into pre-season fit and healthy, unlike last year where he supposedly carried an Achilles injury most of the year (which also highlights how bad Adelaides backup ruckman Angus Graham was that an injured Jacobs was considered a better selection than a healthy Graham).
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Supercoach 2014 turnco... · 0 replies · +2 points
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Supercoach 2014 turnco... · 0 replies · +2 points
10 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - Supercoach 2014 turnco... · 0 replies · +2 points