intensedebater2
17p12 comments posted · 1 followers · following 0
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - Letter from an Inmate · 0 replies · +1 points
The man who wrote this blog seems to be very in touch with his emotions, and with reality. It is interesting to hear the perspective of an inmate straight from their mouths because it makes you think a little differently. For instance, I never thought about how an inmate would feel upon being told about a huge tragedy like Haiti, or Katrina. It must be infinitely frustrating to know that never in your lifetime will you be able to help. The helplessness must get to the inmates on a level that we on the outside cannot comprehend.
The word ‘never’ is hard to fully take in when thinking about your life. Imagine saying, “I will never be able to do that again.” Like, how many things are we as free people never able to do? The world is at our fingertips whether we realize it or not, and the people behind bars never get to experience all of the things that we are able to. I imagine it is not something that the inmates want to think about a lot, as I can’t imagine how depressing it would be, but I wonder at what point during their time behind bars that they fully grasp the concept of life imprisonment. I honestly feel really bad for them.
I obviously think that they should be held accountable for their actions, but I now realize how important it is to not immediately judge a convict. You never know, people can change, and it’s sad that they will never get a second chance. I hope that sometime in my life I will be able to go and talk to ‘lifers’ and give them a chance to have an audience to listen to them, and to provide some sort of assurance that not everyone thinks they are bad people.
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - This is totally off th... · 0 replies · +1 points
I hate to be one of those people who says that what people see in video games can translate over into their real lives, but in some cases I really think it can. Picture adolescent boys who may play this game. Violating girls is not only part of the game, but the ultimate goal. By playing these sort of games day after day, boys may learn to consider these type of terrible actions as the norm. Furthermore, parents who buy these games for their kids are in a way condoning what goes on within the games. A kid’s logic could be, “Well, mom bought me the game, so I guess there is nothing wrong with what I’m doing to the girls in the game.” This logic is clearly a stretch, but you never know when it comes to such serious topics.
Being a person who had a real life experience that involved a close encounter with rape, it is absolutely alarming to me that such a serious subject would be made into a video game. Thinking back to how I felt in the moment where I thought I was going to be raped is one of the harder things I’ve ever had to do. To think that countless people are out there passing their time by getting ‘revenge’ on women who did them wrong by bounding and raping them makes me question the morals of the people who are designing the game. Like, who the hell raised them? And at what point in their lives did they decide that creating such a heinous game was okay?
The funny thing is that we are so numb to the plethora of games that make murder the goal. Taking someone’s life is no game or joke either, and can teach people skewed views of reality as well. However, these murder games have become so prevalent in our society, that no one even turns their heads to them anymore. Whatever happened to good old Super Mario?
One of the weirdest parts of the news clip was when the European girl said that she did not feel offended at all by the game, but instead actually downloaded and played it with her boyfriend/husband (don’t know what he was). This girl clearly has problems if she gets entertainment out of playing a video game that involves seeking out women and raping them. Like, what? I would like to know how her love life is working out….
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - Nothing About the Cens... · 0 replies · +1 points
The most controversial term on the United States Census is probably the word negro. The necessity for this word, however, is a tricky situation. Some older black people in America may still refer to themselves as negroes, and would not bat an eyelash at seeing the term on paper. The majority of black people in America, however, would take great offense to the word negro, as it implies repression and slavery in their minds. How do the researches decide, then, what to keep on the census and what to eliminate? If they keep the word negro, they risk offending the majority of the black population. If they omit the term, the people who identify with it may leave the question blank, as they may not know what other term best fits their ethnicity.
Another concern about the census is that some people do not know whether or not they should classify themselves as white when they have other ethnicities in their background. One woman said that she was white, but seemed a little upset about it because she also identified with having Native American in her blood. Another woman said how she had Hispanic roots but was technically still white. What is the right choice for her? I guess a major issue with the census is that people have a hard time identifying with just one race because there are a lot of “mixed” Americans. In fact, it seems that most Americans are mixed.
The good thing, though, is that the census is formed based on extensive research conducted by qualified personnel. The terms on the census are there for a reason, not just because some racist thought it would be appropriate to include the term negro. I am pretty sure that the term negro will be omitted from the census sometime in the near future as the older population of black Americans begins to die out. I do understand the offense that some of the younger population may take to such an out-dated word, but at the same time, I feel it is necessary for them to realize that such a word is there for a reason, and not meant to offend anyone. With generalization comes offense no matter what the topic, because there are always exceptions to every stereotype.
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - I Reckon She Can Hit · 0 replies · +1 points
In no way am I against a woman coaching football. More power to this girl – she must be an amazing athlete with a ton of sports knowledge. But at the same time I am rather skeptical as to how well she will be able to coach such a rough sport, football. I’m not skeptical that she will have great plays and strategies that she will pass on to her team, but I am just confused at how someone who cannot physically play a sport can coach it. Usually people learn how to perform better in sports by experience, learning their strengths and weaknesses, learning what works and what does not, learning how to get better, etc. It just seems a little strange that this woman is so good at football when she does not even play it.
That aside, I think it is amazing that this woman was chosen for the coaching spot. I can’t imagine the pressure she must feel right now to live up to the high bar that has been set by many people, like me, who are skeptical of how she will perform. Thinking about this, I wonder how the team that she is going to be coaching feels. I can imagine that some of the boys are not too happy that a woman will be coaching them, while some probably do not mind. I bet she will have a hard time proving herself to her team, but I’m sure she will be able to do it. Personally, I really hope that she kicks ass on the field to prove that a woman can prosper in a position that has been strictly a man’s position. This could really be the start to a new era.
I know it’s on a completely different scale, but gender progression like this makes me wonder if we are getting closer to having a female president. In this past presidential election, we were closer than we ever have been to having a woman lead our country. I truly wonder if our country will ever be able to overcome the gender bias that sadly exists. We overcame the racial one (in the sense of the presidency), so who’s to say it couldn’t happen? I guess only time can tell.
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - What's With the Theme ... · 0 replies · +1 points
Through my years at Penn State, I have been to many parties. All of these parties are mostly predictable…show up, drink, get drunk, eat, go home. At all of these parties there have been many different types of people. These people include frat boys, sorority girls, white, black, brown, and all other people in between. And it’s NOT a big deal. Drinking is not race-specific. We all like to have a good time, right? So likewise, theme parties are not race-specific, or as this girl thinks, white specific. It is really interesting to me that this girl has that perception because it is so false. And to think that she thinks that most of them are poking fun at black people? I’ve never heard this generalization before and it makes absolutely no sense.
Think of all the possible themes that there could be for a theme party. There could be a Thanksgiving theme, a Christmas theme, a Mardi Gras theme, a Valentine’s Day theme, or anything else of this sort. In fact, most of the theme parties that I have been to since I’ve been at Penn State have been similar to this, and they in no way have anything to do with ANY race. This girls’ blog post makes me wonder if more people feel the same way as she does. I really hope that this is not the case because it really upsets me to think that black people (or any people) would feel that white people are making fun of them by having theme parties. I can’t even think of a theme party that I’ve ever been to that pokes fun at black people. I’ve heard of CMT versus BET, so I could understand how this could be mis-interpreted. But wouldn’t it be fair to say that this could be making fun of white people too? I’d rather just not pull the race card, because that’s not what theme parties are about.
What’s funny is that I don’t even like theme parties. Every time I hear that there is one I get annoyed because it’s too much effort, and a lot of times I won’t go (unless it’s a fun theme). I have a hard time believing that white people are the only ones to host them, and I know for a fact that people of all races attend them. I really wish that people would see the bigger picture. It may seem like there are more “white” theme parties, but that is simply because white people are the majority at Penn State. I really wish that the girl in this blog did not feel the way she does, because it is not true.
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - Could You Compete With... · 0 replies · +1 points
Let’s pretend for a minute that Yvrose was born in America, raised as an American child, and put through the normal school system. She then went on to college and earned a degree in business, like tons of people all around the country, and at Penn State. So now the very naturally intelligent Yvrose has a college education, and from what we know, would be expected to excel and succeed in all aspects of her business job. But would her non-pressing circumstances motivate her in the same way it motivated her in real life, in Haiti? This blog is taking a different perspective than most, but when I listened to her story, it made me wonder what exactly is it that drives people to greatness.
Like Sam said, some people have a golden-paved road laid out in front of them all of their lives, (nothing against them obviously, it’s just part of the miracle of their birth) but some never really strive to achieve higher than what they get because in many cases they may not be used to really striving for anything. Put that same person in Haiti, however, where their life is yanked out from under them with no warning. Do they just free ride off of what other people do? Or do they strive to be the leader, the businessperson, the successful person and excel in all aspects of what they set their mind to? Yvrose did an amazing job at overcoming her obstacles and working hard to achieve her goal. I just can’t help but wonder if she would rise to the top in America if her circumstances didn’t force her to be so innovative like they do now (I am not in any way trying to undermine what she did…this girl rocks!).
On a more personal note, I am driven to succeed as a marketing major and pursue a high-level career in marketing. It’s weird to think about, though, that my life could be totally different now, and my goal would not be to make six figures, but to find my next meal. I truly wish that everyone could be as fortunate as me and most of us in America because truthfully…what makes us deserve this more than them? Nothing…
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - LGBT Class: Question Six · 1 reply · +1 points
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - Swinging Past the Othe... · 4 replies · +1 points
For example, my dad came from a lower-middle class/poor family in the suburbs of Chicago. His dad (my grandfather) was a shoe salesman, and his mother (my grandma) was an elementary school teacher. Like Sam said, it would have been easy/expected for him to follow in their footsteps given his financial circumstances, but he did not. My dad paid his way through an undergraduate degree at Lawrence University and medical school. He then went on to have a residency at one of the most prestigious hospitals in America, The Mayo Clinic, and got a job as one of the head pulmonologists at the Lancaster General Hospital. The interesting part about his story is that he got denied from nineteen medical schools. Nineteen. Now, I have to be honest, if I got rejected from nineteen medical schools I would probably have given up. Just imagine where my dad would have ended up if he gave up. Not as a doctor, that’s for sure!
By persisting through the hardships of obtaining his degrees, my dad really raised the bar as far as expectations for my family. Another way my dad raised the bar for what I can achieve is by quitting his job at the hospital to pursue his dream and create a company that focuses on preventative medicine. He showed me that being successful doesn’t always directly correlate with making money. My family went from a doctor’s salary to an entrepreneur’s salary ($0 for awhile) in the blink of an eye. But my dad was happy, and was doing good things for society, and that proved to me that I can really do whatever I want with my life, and I don’t have to do what is always expected of me. The slogan that my dad uses to explain why he feels so successful is “I do well by doing good.” Now that sounds like an okay plan to me.
Overall, people need to stop thinking the world is out to get them every time something goes wrong. It is so important to realize that you can walk around the obstacles instead of simply turning away from them and giving up. We are in a world where anything is possible and we need to remember just how lucky we are.
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - Avatar and the White M... · 0 replies · +1 points
I was raised in a very non-judgmental, equality-intensive home, where it was second nature that all people were made equal and the mere color of someone’s skin meant absolutely nothing in terms of one person being above another. Personally, I have no tolerance for people who think they are superior to others in terms of their race. David Brooks is a total idiot. When he said that “nonwhite” people need a white Messiah to lead their crusades he sounded more ignorant than ever. As mentioned in class, it is more likely that people will follow a religious leader that looks like them than one who doesn’t (which is sad but true), but to think that white people are the only people capable of leading a group effectively is the same thing as screaming white power at the top of your lungs.
In many cases, white people are more fortunate than many other races. Whether or not that sounds racist, it’s true. Being more fortunate than others gives us an opportunity to spread what we have been blessed with to others. This does not mean, however, that white people are the only people capable of doing this. It just means that it may happen more often. I mean, white people are the majority, aren’t they? The point I’m trying to make is that no group of people should be responsible to lead all other people. People should want to help others, but not force their beliefs upon others who may not agree.
All in all, the assumptions that were made by David Brooks have little credibility among culturally aware people. It is a sign of ignorance to think that the color of your skin makes you different somehow from someone else. If someone wants to get on their high horse and truly believe that their race is superior to others then fine, but I don’t buy a single bit of it.
16 years ago @ Race Relations Project - I Guess It Pays to Lea... · 0 replies · +1 points
The ironic part about this whole situation is that one would think that we are all Americans, therefore we all know about each other’s cultures. Wrong. The fact that one person’s daily prayer ritual strikes another person as life threatening is truly amusing. I have to be honest… if I was on that plane, I would have definitely been a nervous wreck watching a man strap leather bands around his arms and kneel down to pray. In my ignorant mind, I would have most likely have seen it as a possible threat, or at least would have been very suspicious. Situations like this one are proof that people around the world (or around the country) do not take the time to learn about the cultures that surround us. We’re all American, right? Doesn’t that mean that we are all bound in some way, and therefore should want to learn about each other?
Now, don’t get me wrong, I am not googling other cultures in my free time either. And to my knowledge, not many people are (except for Sam Richards probably). Americans are so comfortable with the niche that they live in that many times it seems completely pointless to learn about other cultures’ niches. Think about the issue at hand, though. If we would all take a little time out of our oh-so-busy lives to learn more about each other, maybe the flight attendant would have been able to recognize what was going on, and would have been able to save the airline a lot of time and money. Also, the anxiety of the passengers and pilots would have been drastically decreased had they known what was truly going on. To me, it seem like it would make a lot more sense to simply become aware, rather than to be paranoid of things that are completely harmless.
Unfortunately, this American attitude will never change for some people, as they will never see the value in learning about others. All of us, however, will hopefully have the desire to become more aware after taking this class with Sam Richards. After all, a little knowledge never hurt anyone, did it?