<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" ?>
<rss version="2.0">
	<channel>
		<title>gdp's Comments</title>
		<language>en-us</language>
		<link>https://www.intensedebate.com/users/614881</link>
		<description>Comments by anti_theist</description>
<item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Will Anti-Islam Sentiment Help or Hurt Church-State Separation?</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/08/will-anti-islam-sentiment-help-or-hurt.html#IDComment94724560</link>
<description>&amp;hellip; Mosquerade -- sideshow by xian theo-political thugs          &lt;b&gt;What&amp;rsquo;s God got to do with religion?  Nothing!&lt;/b&gt;         &amp;bull; There are no religions only religious institutions          Religions as institutions have two components, one imaginary and one real:     1. faith-based mythological and cultic claims &amp;mdash;  an imaginary supernatural component     2. demands to exercise secular power &amp;mdash; an illegitimate political component.     In our secular Republic, there is no executive privilege for God.          &amp;bull; Faith claims are meaningless &amp;mdash; secular pretensions to power based on them are dangerous.          God has been dead since Copernicus. But, 460 years later we&amp;rsquo;re still stuck with religious institutions. They do exist, in disgusting abundance.  Religions are Ponzi schemes perpetrated by clerics. Priest and televangelist, Pope and Supreme Ayatollah, bishop and imam are not God&amp;rsquo;s proxies. They are political ideologues making institutional claims to secular power financed by fraudulently obtained donations.        Imagine a world without religious institutions.          the anti-supernaturalist </description>
<pubDate>Sun, 22 Aug 2010 21:33:32 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/08/will-anti-islam-sentiment-help-or-hurt.html#IDComment94724560</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Some Biblical Prophecies Have Come True</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/08/some-biblical-prophecies-have-come-true.html#IDComment94721905</link>
<description>&lt;i&gt;There are altogether no supernatural phenomena, only supernatural interpretations of phenomena.&lt;/i&gt;  &amp;bull; Science makes predictions.   Information about the precise time, precise duration, exact places on the Earth from which the next 50 years of total solar eclipses will be visible resides today on the Net.   Hundreds of years before the fictional Jesus character, geometric understanding was sufficiently advanced in Greece to predict solar eclipses.  Geology, however, cannot predict with precision when the next killer &amp;lsquo;quake will occur in San Francisco The state of geologic knowledge today offers no better than a probable, but meaningful prediction -- there is a greater than 50% chance that an earthquake of magnitude 7.0 or greater will strike SF within the next 30 years.   The prediction -- in advance -- provides its own parameters for failure. It specifies a time limit, it specifies the severity expected, it provides an estimated probability for such a quake which is consistent with what geological theory and observation permit.  Nevertheless, a killer quake must happen eventually given that SF floats very near where two tectonic plates grinding past one another. And there is no &amp;lsquo;grind&amp;rsquo; without a &amp;lsquo;bump.&amp;rdquo;  &amp;bull; Religion makes prophecies.   Contrast a grand and empty gestures of xianity. A &amp;ldquo;fulfillment&amp;rdquo; of scripture will occur. Jesus in his role as Christ will return to Earth, raise the dead, judge all humanity past and present, and send each person to her or his ultimate and eternal state of being. Ask fundies; they&amp;rsquo;ll tell you that this prophecy is 100% certain.   An apocalypse must happen; it is a dogma of fundie bibliolatry. Millions of otherwise reasonably sane people in the US believe this nonsense, quite literally.  On what non-scriptual basis can that claim be justified? After all, the so-called bible cannot be used to justify its own statements.   Prophecy lacks any falsifying conditions. Under what conditions, specifiable in advance, would a fundie say that a xian prophecy would fail. Attempts to predict a date for the xian apocalypse proved wrong for the last 2,000 years.   Just remember, though, that the End Times are upon us because &amp;ldquo;signs&amp;rdquo; like earthquakes, and total solar eclipses demonstrate it.  the anti_supernaturalist </description>
<pubDate>Sun, 22 Aug 2010 21:07:10 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/08/some-biblical-prophecies-have-come-true.html#IDComment94721905</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Government Prayer and Minority Rights in a Democracy</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/06/government-prayer-and-minority-rights.html#IDComment78522192</link>
<description>. . . in Ameristan, there&amp;#039;s a fundie child indoctrinated into ignorance and arrogance every minute of every day. If you don&amp;#039;t despise fundies, why not? They despise you. You want your rights under the Constitution? Fight them.  &lt;b&gt;the voice of Ameristan is &lt;i&gt;not&lt;/i&gt; the voice of &amp;quot;God&amp;quot;&lt;/b&gt;  &lt;i&gt;Notice to the fundies of Ameristan:&lt;/i&gt;  &amp;bull; &amp;ldquo;Even gods rot &amp;mdash; can&amp;rsquo;t you smell the divine putrefaction?&amp;rdquo; &amp;mdash; Nietzsche. FW sec 125.  &amp;quot;God&amp;quot; is not king; Jesus Christ does not rule. They are dead &amp;mdash; along with Ahura Mazda, YHVH, and Allah. Your priests and pastors, rabbis and imams cannot be divine proxies. They are politicos with delusions of theocracy. Who elevated you over us?  If left to yourselves, the US would immediately become xian Pakistan. If we could keep our federal tax dollars from you, we would. Secede from the Union! Godspeed you on your way. Do you need a theocracy now? Convert to islam. Move to Saudi Arabia where life for 50% of you would be paradise.   Cynical politicians of the Empire said &amp;ldquo;Vox populi, vox dei&amp;rdquo;  The Roman Empire, of course, &amp;ldquo; the voice of the people is the voice of god&amp;quot; --  Give the mob what it wants &amp;mdash; and you are Legion (see Mark 8:22-37 NIV). You are self-righteous maleficent ignoranti, as close to demonic as only true believers can be.  We know you Ameristan. Home to xian Taliban. Home to haters of reason, haters of women, haters of freedom of conscience. Home to disgusting dominionists and wannabe theocrats.  &amp;bull; Don&amp;rsquo;t tread on us, xian oppressors.  Though you remain US citizens, you will never dictate what we should think, what we should believe, how we should behave in accordance with laws we give to ourselves under the Constitution. (Law did not originate in a voice from Sinai, or Mecca, or Jerusalem, or Salt Lake City, or worst of all from televangelist cesspools.)  We expect &lt;i&gt;your rights&lt;/i&gt; to disbelief and freedom from religion under the Constitution to be respected by all in &lt;b&gt;our secular state&lt;/b&gt; from which you benefit more than we. And that includes our right to free speech against your pseudo-1-god on the air, on the internet, on other media including billboards, bus and subway advertising.  If you imagine that the anti_supernaturalist enjoys &amp;quot;freedom of conscience&amp;quot; think again. Atheists are the most despised group in Ameristan. Look at the back of any dollar bill &amp;mdash; &amp;ldquo;In God we trust&amp;rdquo; a cynical imperial slogan supported by our far-right courts&amp;mdash; it&amp;rsquo;s an insult to 16% of the US population and a lighted match at the corner of the US Constitution.  Even if the morally disgusting, vicious, paternalistic 1-god of the big-3 monster-theisms could be proven to exist, even if old Tom Paine&amp;rsquo;s white-washed deistic divinity could be established by Reason &amp;mdash; &lt;i&gt;we have the sovereign right to reject any claim that it must be acknowledged, accepted, or worshiped.&lt;/i&gt;   We have the right (which even you must acknowledge) of going to your non-existent Hell by our own choice. (How else will I get to talk with Xenophanes, Democritus, Epicurus, Lucretius, Diogenes Laertius . . . they knew your kind as frauds and liars before your death impulse even existed.)  All gods are irrelevant to our freedom of conscience -- The de-deification of western culture is our task for the next 100 years.  the anti_supernaturalist </description>
<pubDate>Fri, 4 Jun 2010 15:40:29 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/06/government-prayer-and-minority-rights.html#IDComment78522192</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Can Science Education Work?</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/05/can-science-education-work.html#IDComment72108484</link>
<description>** A wider view needed -- credulous Apes flourish best in US (and Turkey)    Live Science web site has posted information to help understand the problem, and by taking a multinational perspective shows how ignorant the US is compared to Japan, Western Europe, Eastern Europe, but not Turkey...the only country more ignorant than US. So, science will survive nicely even if it dies here in the Empire of Ignorati.    One big problem: the RC church whose pedophile protecting pontiff just yesterday (2 may) venerated the damned &amp;quot;shroud&amp;quot; of Turin! This character out of Kafka has sway over what? -- 500 million believers. Europe resists because Western Europe is vastly more agnostic, atheist, and anti-clerical than the US.    Stopping the spread of supernaturalism in the US means attacking all right-wing religions head-on. With declining real income over the last decade continuing, I expect the pressure to protest against the wrong forces will increase. The corporate/xian/military machine knows how to protect itself and put the blame on godless atheists, illegal aliens, government taxation -- anyone but the elites.    If you want to read about the future US -- then read The Handmaid&amp;#039;s Tale by Margaret Atwood -- published 25 years ago -- it is a portrait of the US becoming more likely every day.    the anti_supernaturalist </description>
<pubDate>Mon, 3 May 2010 17:51:06 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/05/can-science-education-work.html#IDComment72108484</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Life After Atheism</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/04/life-after-atheism.html#IDComment68890895</link>
<description>&lt;b&gt;only supernatural interpretations of phenomena&lt;/b&gt;  &amp;bull; &lt;i&gt;a thought experiment in freedom of conscience you can try at home&lt;/i&gt;  Dare to exercise your rights &lt;i&gt;to disbelief&lt;/i&gt; and &lt;i&gt;to be free from religion&lt;/i&gt;. Consider what rejection of &amp;ldquo;spiritual discourse&amp;quot; brings with it.   First, there would be no supernatural agents, locations, or states whatsoever:  1. No supernatural agents: minds, souls, spirits, ghosts, godlings, gods, God (Allah, YHVH), cosmic soul, the absolute. 2. No supernatural locations: hell, purgatory, heaven, buddha realms, moral world order, Platonic/Plotinian forms 3. No supernatural states:  the numinous, sin, grace, revelation, life after death, illumination, nirvana, buddha mind. 4. No supernatural events: mysterium tremendum, redemption, resurrection, rapture, mystical union, karma, or reincarnation.  Second, nothing would alter in nature: not the Universe, the Solar system, the Earth, physical events, biological events, psychological events. Humanity&amp;rsquo;s supernatural claims say nothing about nature &amp;mdash; unless they are treated as testable hypotheses, each falsifiable.  Third, nature itself would be neither meaningful nor meaningless. Neither a source of comfort, as in natural theology, nor a source of despair, as in existentialism. Both comfort and despair are psychological errors rooted in the same mistaken presupposition that &lt;i&gt;meaning could be found&lt;/i&gt; by searching &amp;ldquo;the starry heavens&amp;rdquo; for divine agents or by quarrying human inwardness for moral certainties or cosmic &amp;ldquo;laws&amp;rdquo;.  There are no supernatural phenomena, only supernatural interpretations of phenomena.  the anti_supernaturalist </description>
<pubDate>Mon, 19 Apr 2010 20:35:12 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/04/life-after-atheism.html#IDComment68890895</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : National Day of Prayer is Unconstitutional</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/04/national-day-of-prayer-is.html#IDComment68885093</link>
<description>...Your time would be well spent reading two brief excerpts from the US Constitution, not just Amendment 1 but also Article VI, Section 3. Remember to fight for your right of freedom of conscience. Atheists are the most despised group in the US.  &lt;b&gt;Notice to believers, especially fundies, on a National Day of Pious Ventriloquism&lt;/b&gt;  &lt;i&gt;Who&amp;rsquo;s pulling your strings, dummy?&lt;/i&gt;  I expect my rights to &lt;i&gt;disbelief&lt;/i&gt; and &lt;i&gt;freedom from religion&lt;/i&gt; under the Constitution to be respected by all in this secular state from which you benefit more than I. And that includes my right to free speech against your nonexistent deities on the air, on the internet, in other media including political cartoons, billboards, bus and subway advertising.  If you imagine that the anti_supernaturalist enjoys &amp;quot;freedom of conscience&amp;quot; think again. Look at the back of any dollar bill &amp;mdash; &amp;ldquo;In God we trust&amp;rdquo; &amp;mdash; that&amp;rsquo;s an insult to 16% of the US population and a lighted match at the corner of the US Constitution. (Same with NDP &amp;mdash; declared unconstitutional by a Wisconsin federal judge on 13 April.*)  Even if the morally disgusting, vicious, paternalistic 1-god of the Big-3 monster theisms could be proven to exist, even if old Tom Paine&amp;rsquo;s white-washed deistic divinity could be established by Reason &amp;mdash; &lt;i&gt;I have the sovereign right to reject any claim that it must be acknowledged, accepted, or worshiped.&lt;/i&gt; The existence of gods is irrelevant to my right to be a member of a secular, open society.  Faith, the trusting suspension of disbelief, has always been theater of the absurd. As a skeptic, belief in your gods is beneath me. The de-deification of western culture is our task for the next 100 years.  the anti_supernaturalist    *&lt;a href=&quot;http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/04/16/AR2010041604626.html&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/arti...&lt;/a&gt;   Article VI. Section 3. The senators and representatives before-mentioned, and the members of the several state legislatures, and all executive and judicial officers, both of the United States and of the several states, shall be bound by oath or affirmation, to support this constitution; but &lt;b&gt;no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States. &lt;/b&gt;  Amendment I. &lt;b&gt;Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof;&lt;/b&gt; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. </description>
<pubDate>Mon, 19 Apr 2010 19:49:08 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2010/04/national-day-of-prayer-is.html#IDComment68885093</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Idiot of the Week: Those Who Insist That Christmas is Under Attack</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/12/idiot-of-week-those-who-insist-that.html#IDComment46948813</link>
<description>** Midwinter Day and the feast of Yule -- reclaim their ancient joy in this life  The Jehovah&amp;#039;s Witnesses, a puritanical xian sect, does not celebrate xmas for exactly the reason given by ghost_knife: it is a &amp;quot;pagan&amp;quot; not a xian holiday.   And a Joyous Yule to FordManiac76 who knows that our ancestors held Midwinter Day (21 Dec) to be the beginning of a new year and a rebirth of the sun. To our pagan heritage we owe decorations of evergreens, holly, ivy and mistletoe, plus a roaring Yule log to light the home and drink to warm the heart. Xians don&amp;#039;t own Midwinter Day or Yule. They are ours to reclaim and enjoy.  Modern xmas is 166 years old. It was Dickens whose &amp;quot;A Christmas Carol&amp;quot; (1843) stimulated a restoration of xmas, which had fallen into disfavor because Puritans had legislated against it, as filled with dissolute dancing and pagan rites. (We&amp;#039;re talking sex here.)  Logically speaking, today&amp;#039;s fundies ought to be waging &amp;#039;the war against xmas&amp;#039; themselves just as their dour and joy hating Pilgrim predecessors did in 17th century New England. But, what can you expect from them, certainly neither joy nor light.  the anti_supernaturalist </description>
<pubDate>Sun, 13 Dec 2009 01:55:41 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/12/idiot-of-week-those-who-insist-that.html#IDComment46948813</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Afghanistan: Is It Winnable?</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/10/afghanistan-is-it-winnable.html#IDComment40992034</link>
<description>. . . speaking of real gods . . . who can resist assuming the semi-divine status of POTUS? No one since Eisenhower . . . and apparently not Obama.  ** POTUS doesn&amp;rsquo;t need a Chrystal ball  Obama dare not reject the sunk-cost fallacy of continuing external warfare &amp;mdash; he has capitulated already, taking on his role as quasi-god POTUS. His military advisors need him to see in his shaving mirror Marcus Aurelius, wise guardian of the Empire.   Could our divinized POTUS cut the military budget by 50%, could his divine genius recall within the borders our far-flung watchers, could his nobly crowned brow conceive and make real a decent life for all. I think not.  POTUS can&amp;rsquo;t hold on to power unless he embraces the &amp;quot;logic of [his] situation&amp;quot; -- aka his &amp;quot;Fate&amp;quot;. Obama and the elites, military and civilian, must alienate the people and sacrifice the lower ranks of the military. Pfc Boots-on-the-Ground might just catch a whisper of Kipling&amp;rsquo;s advice: To a young British soldier.  When you&amp;#039;re wounded and left on Afghanistan&amp;#039;s plains, And the women come out to cut up what remains, Jest roll to your rifle and blow out your brains An&amp;#039; go to your Gawd like a soldier.  Each empire rots in its own particular way. Yet armies from Alexander&amp;rsquo;s to those of the current incarnation of POTUS find in Afghanistan their non plus ultra.  the anti_supernaturalist  </description>
<pubDate>Wed, 28 Oct 2009 18:44:35 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/10/afghanistan-is-it-winnable.html#IDComment40992034</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Idiot of the Week: Bill Donahue (Again)</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/10/idiot-of-week-bill-donahue-again.html#IDComment40440774</link>
<description>** Get rid of xian-Taliban who want an Ameristan  God doesn&amp;#039;t enjoy &amp;ldquo;executive privilege.&amp;rdquo; Let religious operatives form their own political party. Out them all.  Time to eliminate the special IRS status of religions. Tax their property, tax their income, de-fund their parasitical faith-based initiatives. (Obama out-Bushes Bush on this nonsense.) Then we&amp;rsquo;ll see how long their pernicious special interest groups last.  Time to stop xian-taliban (harassers-stalkers-murderers) from enforcing prig morality and unlawful social control, especially at the state, county, and local levels. How&amp;#039;d you like to live in a xian-Pakistan -- Ameristan?  A secular state ought no longer to demand our dollars support xian TV cons, greedy preachers, pedophiles, xian idiots on school boards . . . who cram their non-existent god, fictional good book, lies about the sciences, and perverted values down our throats.  the anti_supernaturalist (gimme enuf space for my name, pls!) </description>
<pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2009 16:24:02 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/10/idiot-of-week-bill-donahue-again.html#IDComment40440774</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Fools for Christ</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/09/fools-for-christ.html#IDComment36620679</link>
<description>&amp;hellip; you must go back to the &lt;b&gt;first western enlightenment&lt;/b&gt; (roughly 300-100 BCE) brought to an end beginning with Paul of Tarsus (who created the Christ of faith 35-65 CE). And there&amp;rsquo;s no need for blasphemy &amp;mdash; xians and their beliefs are filthy enough &amp;mdash; let Paul speak for himself.  &lt;b&gt; Reason is the Devil&amp;#039;s whore -- Luther&lt;/b&gt;  Paul of Tarsus never got over being laughed at in Athens (ca 50 CE) by &amp;quot;a group of Epicurean and Stoic philosophers [who] began to dispute with him.&amp;quot; (Acts 17:18 NIV) The Epicureans put forward an atomic theory as the basis of their cosmology. Both they and the Stoics represented the best of empirical and rational thought in an era not noted for either.  Paul of Tarsus got his revenge in print and xians have followed his nihilistic ideology for 2,000 years:  20-Where is the wise man? Where is the scholar? Where is the philosopher of this age? Has not God made foolish the wisdom of the world? 21-For since in the wisdom of God the world through its wisdom did not know him, God was pleased through the foolishness of what was preached to save those who believe. 22-. . . Greeks look for wisdom, 23-but we preach Christ crucified: . . . foolishness to Gentiles . . . 1Cor1 20-23 NIV (with omissions critical of Jews).  27 God chose the foolish things of the world to shame the wise; God chose the weak things of the world to shame the strong. 28 He chose the lowly things of this world and the despised things, and the things that are not, to nullify the things that are. . .1Cor1:27-28 NIV  Nietzsche saw in few lines the great inversion of values which lies at the diseased core of western culture. His task became &amp;ldquo;the re-valuation of all values&amp;rdquo; -- to overthrow religious institutions and moral &amp;ldquo;intuitions&amp;rdquo; perverted by xian valuations.  Paul and his fellow revenge seekers created a god out of their nihilistic values. He and the primitive church shared a perverse self-understanding characterized by inverted snobbery: &lt;i&gt;We stink, but stinking is good.&lt;/i&gt; Not much has changed 2,000 years later.  Xianity cannot be refuted; it can only be dismantled. The de-deification of culture (including all the sciences) is our task for the next 100 years.  anti_supernaturalist </description>
<pubDate>Wed, 30 Sep 2009 16:15:05 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/09/fools-for-christ.html#IDComment36620679</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : How Prayer Works</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/09/how-prayer-works.html#IDComment36510027</link>
<description>&lt;b&gt; what is prayer?&lt;/b&gt; &lt;i&gt; it&amp;rsquo;s not about what you want -- it&amp;#039;s about what&amp;#039;s wanted from you&lt;/i&gt;  God&amp;#039;s lack of a direct response to prayer is not a response of &amp;#039;no.&amp;#039; It&amp;#039;s simply a non-response. To the priest-pastor-rabbi-imam it is important that &amp;ldquo;God&amp;rdquo; never respond. They&amp;#039;d be out of a job.    To hear God speaking to you directly makes you a likely hysteric or schizophrenic, not a likely saint. (Why is it Jesus rather than Buddha who &amp;quot;appears&amp;quot; to Saul/Paul of Tarsus? Why doesn&amp;#039;t St Teresa of Avila go into sexual ecstasy over Krishna like Rhada and his voluptuous milkmaids?)  Jesus admonished his followers against prayer as asking-for-stuff -- &amp;quot;consider the lilies of the field&amp;quot; -- or prayer as public performance -- &amp;quot;they have their reward.&amp;quot; Even the fiction writers of the so-called gospels knew how to hedge their bets . . . how could a non-existent being respond? By 100 BCE philosophical skepticism had made naive prayer -- let&amp;#039;s-make-a-deal -- or a god&amp;#039;s direct public response -- fire from heaven or thunder over the left shoulder -- literally beyond belief.  Prayer amounts to a purported alignment of a person&amp;#039;s intentions with &amp;quot;the will of God.&amp;quot; Or with the will of Yahweh, Allah, Ahura Mazda. Pick your favorite from the big-4 near eastern monster-theisms. They&amp;#039;re interchangeable.  Prayer, basically, is one fat red herring. The word &amp;#039;prayer&amp;#039; simply gets redefined from let&amp;#039;s-make-a-deal until the action it points to is rendered into attitude adjustment. Now the religious &amp;quot;authorities&amp;quot; have you. All that matters is your attitude -- are you prepared to submit to them as some god&amp;#039;s proxy?  So you have a problem with adapting to authority? -- well it&amp;#039;s your problem. Or better yet, intones father-pastor-rabbi-imam, you are your problem. You&amp;#039;re out of touch with &amp;quot;reality&amp;quot; -- which we know to be the fantasy lands of religious fiction.  Religion and Freudian psychiatry are one in creating fictitious &amp;quot;illnesses&amp;quot; (sin/neurosis) for which each offers bogus cures at premium prices. </description>
<pubDate>Tue, 29 Sep 2009 17:39:24 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/09/how-prayer-works.html#IDComment36510027</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Understanding Atheism and Agnosticism</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/09/understanding-atheism-and-agnosticism.html#IDComment35937287</link>
<description>Accepted meanings of &amp;lsquo;atheism&amp;rsquo; and &amp;lsquo;agnosticism&amp;rsquo; in standard US English  &amp;bull;Main Entry: athe&amp;middot;ism &amp;bull;Pronunciation: \\ˈā-thē-ˌi-zəm\\ &amp;bull;Function: noun &amp;bull;Etymology: Middle French ath&amp;eacute;isme, from ath&amp;eacute;e atheist, from Greek atheos godless, from a- + theos god &amp;bull;Date: 1546 1 archaic : ungodliness, wickedness  2 a : a disbelief in the existence of deity b : the doctrine that there is no deity &lt;a href=&quot;http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/atheism&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/atheism&lt;/a&gt;  &amp;bull;Main Entry: ag&amp;middot;nos&amp;middot;tic &amp;bull;Pronunciation: \\ag-ˈn&amp;auml;s-tik, əg-\\ &amp;bull;Function: noun &amp;bull;Etymology: Greek agnōstos unknown, unknowable, from a- + gnōstos known, from gignōskein to know &amp;mdash; more at know &amp;bull;Date: 1869 1 : a person who holds the view that any ultimate reality (as God) is unknown and probably unknowable; broadly : one who is not committed to believing in either the existence or the nonexistence of God or a god  2 : a person unwilling to commit to an opinion about something &amp;lt;political agnostics&amp;gt;  &lt;a href=&quot;http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/agnostic&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/agnosti...&lt;/a&gt;   ** Why not start simply and build from there?  This thread is really tangled. From the very start one is faced with terms drawn from a not always helpful specialized (philosophical) vocabulary.  Instead, start with definitions of words as used in everyday discourse and writing. I used Merriam-Webster&amp;rsquo;s site. It is a publisher of dictionaries which are authoritative for standard American English.   One point to note: &amp;lsquo;atheism&amp;rsquo; like &amp;lsquo;atheist&amp;rsquo; can be traced back 2,500 years directly to classical Greek. &amp;lsquo;Agnostic&amp;rsquo; however is only 140 years old. Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-1895) &amp;mdash; coined the word to characterize his own stance towards the xian religion. Huxley is best known as a tireless defender of Darwin&amp;rsquo;s theory of evolution, as &amp;ldquo;Darwin&amp;rsquo;s Bulldog.&amp;rdquo;  &amp;mdash; anti_supernaturalist (too long to be an acceptable name on this site) </description>
<pubDate>Fri, 25 Sep 2009 19:42:28 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/09/understanding-atheism-and-agnosticism.html#IDComment35937287</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Deconstructing the Atheist Movement</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/09/deconstructing-atheist-movement.html#IDComment33238460</link>
<description>&lt;b&gt;organizations already exist&lt;/b&gt;  . . . if you are a joiner, there are a large number of voluntary membership organization which cater to atheists etc. Freedom from Religion Foundation or American Humanist Association come to mind immediately -- why not profile them? --   However, just by being a vocal anti-theocrat you can do a lot of good by keeping up sites like this one. A truly secular culture gets built one person at a time.   The fundies&amp;#039; &amp;quot;freedom of religion&amp;quot; depends on everyone&amp;#039;s prior granting of &amp;quot;freedom of conscience&amp;quot; to all -- this is the core of the first amendment, freedom &lt;i&gt;from&lt;/i&gt; religion, freedom from religious tyranny. </description>
<pubDate>Sat, 5 Sep 2009 16:45:15 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/09/deconstructing-atheist-movement.html#IDComment33238460</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Telling Your Family That You Are An Atheist</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/08/telling-your-family-that-you-are.html#IDComment30269380</link>
<description>&lt;b&gt;Becoming-who-you-are requires skepticism and self-assertion&lt;/b&gt;  The word &amp;lsquo;islam&amp;rsquo; means submission. Obviously submission to the will of Allah, as prescribed in the five pillars of faith. The big-3 monotheisms are alike in dismissing an individual&amp;rsquo;s will, &amp;ldquo;not my will but thy will done&amp;rdquo; as we&amp;rsquo;re shown in the poignant scene at Gethsemane in the NT.  &lt;i&gt;Legitimate self-assertion, honest questioning, and personal growth get condemned as insubordination and rebellion.&lt;/i&gt;  With characteristic, combative verve, Kierkegaard condemns the skeptic as as a rebel against revealed faith:  &amp;ldquo;They would have us believe that objections against Christianity come from doubt. This is always a misunderstanding. Objections against Christianity come from insubordination, unwillingness to obey, rebellion against all authority. Therefore, they have been beating the air against the objectors, because they have fought intellectually [against] doubt, instead of fighting ethically [against] rebellion. . . .So it is not properly doubt but insubordination.&amp;rdquo; (Lowrie 122) Thus, SK.  It&amp;rsquo;s not surprising that even attempting to leave a religious culture which demands &amp;rsquo;subordination&amp;rsquo; or &amp;rsquo;submission&amp;rsquo; to someone else&amp;rsquo;s interpretation of an alleged &amp;ldquo;will of god&amp;rdquo; will adversely affect the psychological well-being of the &amp;ldquo;apostate.&amp;rdquo; Guilt feelings get induced. Needless guilt is the elder brother of nonexistent &amp;ldquo;sin.&amp;rdquo;  Becoming-who-you-are or &amp;ldquo;individuation&amp;rdquo; (to use Jung&amp;rsquo;s terminology) is the goal of personal growth. It cannot occur without self-doubt or without doubting authority and authority figures.  When you&amp;rsquo;ve made a &amp;ldquo;leap of faith&amp;rdquo; into hyper-religious space there is no return except by self-assertion, and doubt is just a form of it. Prometheus replaces Jesus as an appealing mythological type. (The hero is not a god.)  Irrational self-assertion characterizes much popular culture, the &amp;ldquo;secular&amp;rdquo; culture. Irrational fideism characterizes fundamentalism, jewish, xian, or islamic.  Tolerance, that wide band of humane behavior, lies between inhuman anarchy and inhuman puritanism. Trying to navigate in that band requires years of training and making a lot of mistakes.  the anti_supernaturalist </description>
<pubDate>Mon, 10 Aug 2009 15:38:30 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/08/telling-your-family-that-you-are.html#IDComment30269380</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Misunderstanding Science in Some Unlikely Places</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/08/misunderstanding-science-in-some.html#IDComment29387905</link>
<description>&lt;b&gt;Natura naturans: atheists restore to nature its &amp;quot;innocence&amp;quot; &lt;/b&gt;  &lt;i&gt;The de-deification of western culture (including the sciences) is our task for the next 100 years.&lt;/i&gt;  &amp;bull;  we free culture from the dead hand of near eastern mythological speculation  A mishmash of near eastern magical texts makes spurious claims of being god-given. Their nihilistic dualism and androcentric understanding of the universe and of human nature are too damaging to contribute to a humane planet-wide ethos.  &amp;bull; we free culture from the death impulse characterized by &amp;quot;sin&amp;quot; and &amp;quot;guilt&amp;quot;  The universe evinces neither affect, nor morality, nor intellect. Neither physical nature nor human nature &lt;i&gt;say&lt;/i&gt; anything about a superordinate, supernatural realm populated by creators or law givers.   Nature is silent. There is no concept of truth in nature. Indeed, there are no concepts whatsoever in nature. Nature &lt;i&gt;knows&lt;/i&gt;nothing. Natura naturans. Nature acts.  Nature is neither meaningful nor meaningless. Neither a source of comfort (natural theology) nor a source of despair (existentialism). Both are rooted in the same mistaken presupposition that supernatural &lt;i&gt;meaning&lt;/i&gt; can be found by searching &amp;ldquo;the starry heavens&amp;rdquo; for gods or by quarrying human inwardness for moral laws.  &amp;bull; we show that religion is a needless cultural artifact  Religions belong to cultures embedded in nature. And &lt;i&gt;cultures&lt;/i&gt; are our distinctive human-all-too-human handiwork. Religions are obsolete, replaceable cultural artifacts.  Any specific religion reenacts and institutionalizes cultic myth. It gets spread through recruitment and custom, financially supported by mores and law, and enforced by intimidation and violence.  Xian mythology, like related big-4 monotheisms zoroastrianism, post-exilic judaism, and islam, posits a moralized universal order which never existed. No more can be found in &amp;ldquo;the starry heavens&amp;rdquo; than the ancestors put into it. (Theology is fifth-rate fan fiction.)  &amp;bull; we show that god-given morality is (rooted in) imperial propaganda  Some of that pseudo-meaning derives ultimately from Sargon I&amp;rsquo;s (2334-2279 BCE) imperial propaganda when the very first violent yoking together of disparate Sumerian city-state cultures occurred in what is now Iraq.  Sargon I appears on a low relief sculpture as a god receiving a legal and moral code directly from a greater god enthroned above him. A myth of divine origin of royalty and morality turns out to be ancient &lt;i&gt;political spin&lt;/i&gt;. (Still works today, doesn&amp;rsquo;t it?)  * we present a &amp;quot;way&amp;quot; superior to the world hating monster-theisms  Adjust your understanding, adjust your expectations, and you will have a right relationship with the only total reality there is, natura naturans. Nature naturing &amp;mdash; without any gods&amp;rsquo; assistance.  anti_supernaturalist (your system doesn&amp;#039;t accept long user names!) </description>
<pubDate>Tue, 4 Aug 2009 05:35:26 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/08/misunderstanding-science-in-some.html#IDComment29387905</guid>
</item><item>
<title>Atheist Revolution : Why Atheists Object to Engraving \&quot;In God We Trust\&quot; on the Capitol Visitor Center</title>
<link>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/07/why-atheists-object-to-engraving-in-god.html#IDComment28334997</link>
<description>. . . federal courts have spoken on IGWT before, and not favorably for non-theists. &amp;quot;God&amp;quot; is not what most xians or non-theists think IT is. &amp;#039;God&amp;#039; as you&amp;#039;ll see trades on the ambiguity of It&amp;#039;s name.   &lt;b&gt;** FfR probably won&amp;rsquo;t win -- but it should fight anyway **&lt;/b&gt;    US Courts have consistently held that &amp;#039;God&amp;#039; in the notorious &amp;quot;In God We Trust&amp;quot; refers to a one-size-fits-all unique &lt;i&gt;deistic divinity&lt;/i&gt; &amp;mdash; IT, creator, sustainer of the universe consistent with Western tradition. (The use of IGWT goes back to its use on Union coinage during the Civil War.)    I call it IT -- since IT has no gender -- IT is the Minimum Standard God, or MSG. This illegitimate &amp;#039;god of the state&amp;#039; belongs to no religion. MSG is a hypothesized monotheistic entity.     I expect US courts to trot out MSG as precedent for beating back atheists&amp;#039; challenge to the &amp;#039;under God&amp;#039; clause in the pledge of allegiance &amp;mdash; MSG is today invoked before each Supreme Court session and each House of Congress opens with a prayer &amp;mdash; recently delivered by a Hindu who was booed from the House Gallery by radical xian know-nothings.    Courts will argue that the concept of MSG does not violate the establishment clause. Traditionally, Westerners have averred that MSG would answer their basic notion of a &amp;#039;god.&amp;#039; The MSG concept is certainly non-sectarian.    No one is legally obligated to equate MSG with that moral monster embraced by Dobson, Hagee and all fundies. Or, the merely xian &amp;quot;God&amp;quot; of C.S. Lewis. Or, &amp;quot;God&amp;quot; as Paul Tillich&amp;#039;s &amp;quot;ultimate concern.&amp;quot; And, deists can claim that their &amp;quot;God&amp;quot; has no more interest in the universe than the gods of Epicurus.    Unfortunately, tradition also dictates that MSG exist. Tradition leaves open any god hypothesis, except of course denying the existence of a unique god however bland. (That is however &amp;quot;logically weak&amp;quot; or &amp;quot;pared down&amp;quot; the concept.)    Still remaining outside MSG&amp;rsquo;s embrace: atheists, agnostics, secular humanists, Theravada Buddhists, Chinese ancestor worshipers, Shintoists, Hindus, Vedantists, Wiccans, assorted polytheists, devil worshipers . . . those few too principled to be hypocrites . . . and legions of the wholly indifferent.     Millions are discriminated against -- because they are not consenting monotheists.    Demand &amp;quot;Freedom from Religion&amp;quot; -- state neutrality, no support of monotheism, however attenuated. Like other hallowed traditions -- slavery, Jim Crow laws, male only suffrage -- IGWT violates both the spirit and the law as stated in Amendment 1 of the Constitution.    Moving on . . . let&amp;#039;s see that the tax exemption be removed from all religious organizations which engage in political activities -- roman catholicism, judaism, dominionist fundies would make a healthy start.    anti_theist </description>
<pubDate>Sat, 25 Jul 2009 15:55:41 +0000</pubDate>
<guid>http://www.atheistrev.com/2009/07/why-atheists-object-to-engraving-in-god.html#IDComment28334997</guid>
</item>	</channel>
</rss>