Robert Dwyer
81p736 comments posted · 2 followers · following 0
5 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Modeling Value: Introd... · 0 replies · +1 points
And thanks for continuing the conversation about QPR comparisons.
First off, I agree it doesn't make sense to compare scores between critics. Some just tend to throw big numbers around more readily than others and you have to account for that and normalize the scores if you're going to trust the critic at all.
The second article is interesting as well, most memorably for me how I myself am unsure how much I'd like a critic to alter their score based on differences in the wines they taste. Specifically: Say a critic from Spectator is tasting a bunch of California Zinfandel. 80% of them roughly taste the same. 10% probably stand out as being better, 10% of them probably fall short/have some off notes. How would I like the critic to rate these wines? 90-91 for the winners, 86-88 for the mid-range, and 82-84 for the losers? I think that's what we get. But what if the critic distibuted them more widely within say the 94-78 point range? That would certainly get my attention more but would, I think, be inconsistent with the way Spectator has historically done things. So what we get is a big clump of wines tightly clustered together in their ratings. And perhaps that's as it should be - because they're really quite similar in quality.
However you slice it whether the standout wines, when purchased, are "good" in my estimation will determine whether I come back and buy them again.
Is all of this an effective means of discovering value wines? Hard to say. I've played that game with varying degrees of intensity over the years and results are mixed. I will say I've discovered a reliable stable of producers that I consistently enjoy. But over time those producers might trail off in quality and I'll miss out on some new up and comers. And that's where you have to get out and refresh the categories you're shopping in and the producers you're trying.
Lots of different ways to find these value wines. Going off scores is just one of them.
My email address is: wellesleywinepress@gmail.com
6 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Maximizing the 2017 Wi... · 0 replies · +1 points
So it takes some finagling with the denominations. It only really breaks down when you try to order very expensive single bottles.
6 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Maximizing the 2017 Wi... · 0 replies · +1 points
7 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Which Grocery Stores i... · 0 replies · +1 points
7 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Giveaway: 2 Tickets to... · 0 replies · +1 points
7 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Giveaway: 2 Tickets to... · 0 replies · +1 points
7 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - 5 Outstanding Italian ... · 0 replies · +1 points
7 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Monte Oton: The Amazin... · 0 replies · +1 points
8 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Just When I Was About ... · 0 replies · +1 points
I'm headed down to DC this weekend. Let me see if I'll be near Calvert Woodley.
8 years ago @ The Wellesley Wine Press - Just When I Was About ... · 1 reply · +1 points
Nice to hear from you!