IntenseDebate - SC

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - TEAM REVEAL: FOZDADDY · 0 replies · +2 points

Like what you're laying down here, Foz. The three rookie forward line still scares me, TK to Green would give you some cash to play with to upgrade one or two

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - TEAM REVEAL: KEV · 0 replies · +1 points

Fair. Not many seem to be a fan. As I said, don’t love the pick but if Naismith goes down R2 I’m stuck with a 250k rock and zero options. Might need to reassess

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - TEAM REVEAL: KEV · 2 replies · +2 points

Cheers, Rogan. Like getting the thoughts of fans. Off the top of my head he was the top wing attendee for the Dogs in both preseason games. I’ll double check that. I like him because he can get 25-30 possessions a game without much fuss. Kicks more than he handballs. He just feels underpriced

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - TEAM REVEAL: KEV · 1 reply · +1 points

Would you go all in and just hope Naismith can last? Cameron would be the only other DPP ruck I’d consider

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - TEAM REVEAL: KEV · 0 replies · +1 points

Cheers for the intel, derek. I reckon if there’s a forward rookie between now and R1 I like it’ll be Ceglar down and I’ll jump off the Naismith experiment

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - TEAM REVEAL: KEV · 1 reply · +1 points

Nothing against Whitfield. Just couldn’t get him in.

As long as Rankine is fit he plays, the risk is we don’t know his scoring power. Would depend on your structure as there isn’t even one fwd rookie that I would field with confidence week in week out. If Rankine disappoints at F5 then F5-8 is a bit of a lottery from week to week

Like the English call. I’m a fan too and with the midfield he had at his feet his HTA stats should rise

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - TEAM REVEAL: KEV · 0 replies · +1 points

Thanks, DZ. It's a good idea, I'd rather go less heavy in the middle and go one up/down with McC and Hunter, giving me approx 350k left over to strengthen elsewhere. Probably one less rookie defender or turning Naismith into Goldy if I can stretch it.

Not in love with the idea of a 5 premium mid however, as I find it the hardest line to upgrade. Especially with cash generation looking like it will be hard to come by. I'll keep tinkering!

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - MARSH SERIES REPORT | ... · 3 replies · +2 points

It's the ol' "better for the run" conundrum. Good to get minutes into him but we've got other options. Looking forward to seeing Cerra again next week

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - MARSH SERIES REPORT: M... · 1 reply · +7 points

I contribute to this site Kevin, so yeah, I have a vested interest in it and what goes on in the comments.

All I'm saying is have an opinion, but don't get personal. It's easy to do. If you want to take anonymous pot shots at people, there's plenty of places you can do that

Good luck for 2020

4 years ago @ Jock Reynolds - MARSH SERIES REPORT: M... · 1 reply · +14 points

Sick of comments like these. You're entitled to your opinion George, everyone is, but why make the personal attack on Patch who has given up a few hours of his Saturday to do this writeup? There's no money involved, he, and the other guys that contribute to this site, do it because we have a shared love of footy and SuperCoach. If you don't like the tone of the article I can think of half a dozen other SC sites off the top of my head that will give you stats from the game.

Re: Trac. We're not stupid. We know his history. But honestly, 5th year player, high draft pick, contract year, and played a chunk of mid time yesterday. Yes it was a practice match and yes neither team were full strength, but a performance like that warrants further attention

IntenseDebate Comment System

Connect with SC_Kev7

People I'm following

SC_Kev7