I agree partially. 2k9 is not nearly as bad as everyone is saying. the people who play like 2 innings and start bitching that the wind speed isnt accurate, and that manny ramirez's hair is 2inches too long are just lame. Ive played about 10 full games and have had no issues really at all. I played a 5-3 game as the r.sox vs. yankees and had no homeruns and no glitches.

Last year i bought a ps3 due to how everyone was jerking off to how great the show was, and it felt like i was playing it all over again on my ps2 (aka 2006). the show feels so last gen, and the controls are so damn basic its lame as hell. 2k9 has great commentary, graphics, motions, sure its not the greatest game ever ( i'm still pissed you cant choose a created players motion/stances), but personally i think its a lot of fun to play.

p.s. comerica park only has 39,999 seats in the game, but in real life there are 40.000. the nerve.

This game is not nearly as bad as everyone is saying. Clearly its got issues, but its a good game.

But, is it just me, or can you no longer choose your created players batting stance/pitching motion?

Also, in response to the whole not being able to pitch while the batter is in his prestance motion, all you have to do is press the A button, and it will skip right through it.